Penny Nichols and the Knob Hill Mystery — Story, Setting & Ideas

(0 User reviews) 469

In Category - Childrens Adventures

Authors: Clark, Joan, 1905-2002 Digital Source: Project Gutenberg Gutenberg Release Year: 2010 First Publication Year: Not confirmed

Key Word: Detective and mystery stories; Vacations -- Juvenile fiction; Brigands and robbers -- Juvenile fiction; Wills -- Juvenile fiction Target Reader: Readers of public-domain and historical texts

Book Edition: Project Gutenberg digital edition Book Language: en

Edition facts

Words 40,385

Reading time 176 min

Text sections 6

Before opening Penny Nichols and the Knob Hill Mystery — Story, Setting & Ideas, the edition data offers a quick orientation: 40,385 words, 2 hr 56 min estimated reading time, and 6 detected text sections.

The text analysis averages about 10.6 words per sentence, while the detected sections provide another way to judge how the source is divided.

Project Gutenberg metadata also associates the work with “Detective and mystery stories,” connecting these edition facts with the source record’s subject description.

Source: Project Gutenberg record #33383

Penny Nichols expects a dull vacation at Knob Hill, but a locked attic, missing letters, and a mysterious old man quickly turn the cottage into a puzzle. The story moves between the rented cottage, a ravine, and an ancient mansion, with clues hidden in trunks and toy lanterns.

Editorial Edition Score 4.7/5

★★★★★ ★★★★★

Calculated from edition completeness, EPUB availability, text structure and catalogue metadata. Not a user rating.

How this score is calculated

Description quality20 pts
Title & short description10 pts
Source metadata20 pts
Text length15 pts
Chapters / structure15 pts
EPUB file integrity20 pts

Total of 100 points, scaled to a 2.5-5.0 range. Editions with an empty description or a missing EPUB file are not scored.

Edition quality

File: pg33383

Read the Text

I. A COTTAGE AT KNOB HILL II. HELPING A STRANGER III. A QUEER OLD MAN IV. INSIDE INFORMATION V. A NIGHT VISITOR VI. THE ATTIC DOOR VII. PENNY'S DISCOVERY VIII. THE TOY LANTERN CLUE IX. HERMAN CROCKER'S VISIT X. SEARCHING THE LOFT XI. AID FROM MICHAEL XII. THE MATRON'S STORY XIII. A BOLT OF CLOTH XIV. A CONVERSATION OVERHEARD XV. THE MISSING LETTERS XVI. A LOST HANDKERCHIEF XVII. A NEW CLUE XVIII. INSIDE THE GABLED HOUSE XIX. MICHAEL'S ADMISSION XX. ALIAS JAY KLINE

Penny Nichols and the

A Cottage at Knob Hill

Penny Nichols, hair flying in the wind, came running up the steps of the Altman porch. She did not need to ring the bell, for just at that moment Susan, her dark-haired chum, appeared in the open doorway.

"Why, hello, Penny," greeted the Altman girl. "You're all out of breath."

"I ran most of the way from home," replied Penny.

"I was hoping you'd drop in today. Come on into the house."

"No, I can't, Susan," said Penny hurriedly. "I just ran over to say good-by."

"Good-by?" echoed Susan blankly. "You're not going away, Penny?"

"Yes, Dad took a sudden notion he wanted to spend a quiet vacation at a place called Knob Hill. We're motoring down there this afternoon."

"Well, I like that!" exclaimed Susan. "You didn't say a thing about it when we were playing tennis yesterday."

"How could I when I didn't know anything about it myself until an hour ago? That's the way Dad does things, Susan."

"I suppose you're going off on another one of those exciting mystery cases," Susan said enviously.

"I only wish we were," sighed Penny. "This vacation won't be a bit exciting. Dad just wants a complete rest at a quiet place. He says he'll not even think about work while we're gone."

"What sort of place is Knob Hill?"

"From all I can learn it's just a dead spot on the map," Penny declared. "And we've rented a cottage sight unseen."

"Oh, it may not be half bad," said Susan encouragingly. "You'll probably be able to do a lot of interesting things--swim, hike or ride."

"Not at Knob Hill," replied Penny, shaking her head. "It isn't a summer resort place at all. There will be absolutely nothing to do except eat, sleep, and grow fat."

Susan laughed as she glanced at her chum's slender figure. Penny was too active and athletic ever to be plump. She had sparkling blue eyes, golden hair, and a natural smile. It was very easy for her to make friends.

"I haven't finished my packing yet," said Penny. "I'll have to get back home or I'll keep Dad waiting."

"I'm terribly sorry to see you go," Susan told her. "Don't forget to send me a postcard now and then."

Penny promised that she would write often, and then, aware that time was slipping away, said a hurried farewell. Reaching her own home, a large white house on Hilburn Street, she found her father washing the car in the back yard.

Christopher Nichols was a tall, slim man with graying hair. For many years he had been in charge of the Nichols Detective Agency and was well known not only in Belton City but throughout the state. Many persons believed that Penny had inherited her father's sleuthing ability, for even at the age of fifteen she had shown remarkable talent in solving mystery cases.

As Penny paused for a moment to chat with her father before going into the house, she noticed the tired lines of his face.

"Dad really needs a long rest," she thought. "I ought to be glad we're both running off to a quiet place like Knob Hill."

"Hello, Penny," Mr. Nichols greeted his daughter. "I'll have this cleaning job done in another ten minutes. Then I'm ready to start whenever you are."

"You seem anxious to get away from Belton City," Penny smiled. "You're not trying to escape from any creditors?"

"Nothing like that," laughed Mr. Nichols. "I'm just sick and tired of the Nichols Detective Agency. For two weeks I intend to forget everything remotely connected with investigation work. Why, if a thief broke into the house tonight and stole our diamonds, I'd not interest myself in the case!"

"That's what you say now," chuckled Penny. "Anyway, we haven't any diamonds."

"Inspector Harris tried to tempt me with a case only today," the detective went on, his face becoming serious again. "I told him I couldn't take it."

"You've earned the right to your vacation," Penny declared.

Mr. Nichols glanced quickly at his daughter.

"You're not very anxious to go to Knob Hill, are you, Penny?" he asked.

"Why--what makes you think that?" Penny stammered. The question had caught her off guard.

Continue Reading →

Penny Nichols expects a dull vacation at Knob Hill, but the narrative immediately undercuts that expectation. The opening scene—Penny running up porch steps, breathless, saying goodbye to her chum Susan—establishes a pattern of hurried movement and interrupted conversations. The cottage is rented sight unseen, a detail that primes the reader for surprises. Within the first chapter, the setting shifts from the Altman porch to the Nichols home to the road to Knob Hill, a restlessness that mirrors Penny’s own energy. The mystery begins not with a crime but with a locked attic door and a queer old man, introduced through overheard remarks and glimpsed figures. The story’s structure relies on these quick scene changes and partial revelations, drawing the reader forward through a series of small discoveries rather than a single dramatic event.

Movement Between Scenes

The narrative rarely lingers. Penny runs up steps, dashes home to pack, motors to Knob Hill, and within pages is exploring the attic. This constant motion is not just a stylistic tic; it shapes how information is revealed. Clues emerge during transitions: a conversation overheard while walking, a discovery made while climbing stairs. The ravine becomes a recurring location for private talks, a space apart from the cottage where Penny and Susan exchange theories. The story’s rhythm—short scenes linked by travel or movement—keeps the reader oriented toward what will be found next, not what has already been settled.

Recurring Images: Trunks, Lanterns, and Letters

Three objects appear repeatedly: a trunk, a toy lantern, and a packet of letters. The trunk in the attic is opened, searched, and found empty of the letters Penny expected. The toy lantern, mentioned in the chapter title “The Toy Lantern Clue,” is a physical object that carries investigative weight. Letters are lost, taken, or hidden—Penny reflects that “someone has taken the letters” and speculates about who might have them. These items are not merely props; they are the material evidence around which the mystery coheres. The story treats them with a detective’s attention, noting their absence as carefully as their presence.

The Housekeeper as Observer

Mrs. Masterbrook, the housekeeper, is introduced as a figure who “seemed to escape nothing.” Penny feels watched: “nothing seemed to escape the vigilant eye of the woman.” The housekeeper appears at doorways, calls out at inconvenient moments, and is suspected of taking the letters. She is a character defined by her surveillance, not by dialogue or action. The story uses her to create a sense of limited privacy within the cottage. Penny and Susan must walk to the ravine to speak freely, explicitly noting that “even the walls have ears.” This dynamic turns the domestic space into a stage where every movement may be observed.

Incomplete Evidence and Inference

The excerpts show a mystery built on partial knowledge. Penny finds the trunk empty of letters but does not know who took them. She speculates about Herman Crocker or Mrs. Masterbrook, but the text offers no confirmation. The missing letters “had not contained anything of vital significance” in Penny’s opinion, yet their disappearance drives the plot. The story does not resolve these questions within the provided material; instead, it leaves the reader with Penny’s hypotheses. This structure—presenting clues without immediate answers—encourages the reader to weigh possibilities alongside the protagonist, without the comfort of an omniscient narrator.

Readers approaching Penny Nichols and the Knob Hill Mystery will find a story that rewards attention to physical objects and offhand remarks. The narrative moves quickly, so tracking who enters and exits a scene matters. The excerpts do not reveal the full solution, but they establish a pattern: Penny’s assumptions are often overturned by new information. Treat each clue as provisional, and note when characters are alone or observed. The mystery unfolds not in grand revelations but in the accumulation of small, sometimes contradictory details.

There’s something about a hidden-attic mystery that stays with you long after the cottage grows quiet. I felt that way reading about Penny’s search among dusty trunks, and it reminded me of another favorite, Pemrose Lorry, Camp Fire Girl — Edition Insights, where the same gentle pull of secret places lingers. Some stories just settle softly into memory, like a lantern left glowing.